John died without any clear heirs in the purple.
The throne was contested between:
-
Henry, his youngest son born legitimate, 10 years before his reign.
-
Catherine, his youngest child born legitimate, 4 years before his reign.
-
Joan, his legitimised daughter, born in the purple.
Joan, legitimised by Papal bull, was held to be the true heir, in part because Henry was at the time a widower.